Sheffield Broomhill Methodist New Connection Chapel
We are very grateful to Neville Flavell for sharing his work on this chapel.
There are two photographs of the chapel on ‘Picture Sheffield’.
One of the building as a whole:
https://www.picturesheffield.com/frontend.php?keywords=Ref_No_increment;EQUALS;s05000&action=zoom
and one of it during demolition:
https://www.picturesheffield.com/frontend.php?keywords=Ref_No_increment;EQUALS;s31064&action=zoomBy Philip Thornborow (24/02/2026)Sheffield Broomhill Methodist New Connection Chapel
In September 1861 a leaflet was produced by Sheffield MNC South Circuit to publicise the intention to buils a new chapel at Broomhill. The site. ‘a most eligible plot of land’, between Westbourne Road and Ashdell Road at their junction with Glossop Road, had already been secured. Besides the commencemnet of a subscription programme, the leafley announced the holding of a fund-raising bazaar at easter of the following year. From what is believed to be the first eveny of such a kind held in Sheffield for church purposes an amazing £961 was raised.
Mark Firth, who himself had given £500 towards the building, laid the foundation stone on 5th May 1862. Rev. D. Round presented the trowel and Rev. Dt. James Satcey, Principal of Ranmoor Collge, gave the address. The same evening Mr Firth ‘announced his purpose to furnish the cahepl with an organ’. [ A full account may be read in the Methodist New Connexion Magazine for 1862 pp 380-384]. The chapel was opened on 23rd April 1863, and in January 1864 the new organ by ‘Father’ Willis of Liverpool was inaugurated by Dr. Samuel Sebastian Wesley. [Another full account appeared in the Methodist New Connexion Magazine for 1864 pp191-192].
By 1868 the entire debt on the building was repaid, in 1883 the chapel was altered and redecorated and a new house was buuilt for the caretaker, and in 1890 Messrs. Willis added a third manual to the organ.
By 1941 Circuit minutes indicate awareness of Broomhill’s decline: congrgations rarely exceeded 35. The Church Meeting of January 1942 unanimously agreed to amalgamate with Nether Green.
The premises were put up for sale, but were requisitioned by the army in 1943. They were finally sold to Walsh’s Department Store in 1946.
The organ was transferred to Neth Green,
The Broomhill site is now occupied by an office block named Pegasus House.Flavell, Neville ‘From Goole Green to Nether Green: the roots and history of Hallam Methodist Church 1756-2006’
By Neville Flavell (24/02/2026)Seven Kings United Methodist Free Church
The 1904-05 chapel seems to have been the subject of a contemporary postcard.
By Philip Thornborow (22/02/2026)

Sheffield Nether Green United Methodist chapel
At Andover Street in October 1899 the Sheffield West Circuit (MNC) Quarterly Meeting heard ‘with pleasure that a site for a new school and chapel at Ranmoor has been secured and pladges itself to do all it can to further that enterprise.’ This chapel was the direct outcome of the interest and efforts of the principlas and students of the nearby Ranmoor College.
After the purchase of a piece of former farmland in July 1900 for £830 the trustees launched the first phase in red brick -the current ‘old hall’ in October. [The plan shows this phase, and the original building can been seen at the rear in the architect’s drawing.]
The new building opened on Sunday June 23rd 1901.
Despite a small membership of 21 the debt on the building was wiped out in October 1903. In 1906 the premises were declared ‘inadequate’ and a Plan Committee were considering proposals from six architects, settling on the designs of W.H. Higginbottom of Nottingham. Negotiations and discussions continued for five years to 1911.
Work began in September 1911 and was completed in the following May, opening on 16th May 1912. The following day The Sheffield Daily Independent reported
“The church, which is a stone building of Gothic design, faces the junction of Nether Green Road and Fulwood Road. Th ebuilding is of local stone with dressings of Stoke stone. Both the exterior and the interior are marked by simplicity. The internal work is in pitch pine which is also used for seating. A glass screen cuts off the entrance from the body of the church. There are no galleries and the choir stalls directly face the congregation. An interesting feature of the construction is the sloping floor which is designed as in the case of many modern chapels to enable the congregation to see the preacher’s face. The interior is very light and airy and the spacious windows are glassed with ornamental leaded lights. Electric lighting has been installed. The heating is by low pressure hot water, and the ventilation is on the natural system. A small lecture hall with choir vestry and minister’s vestry are provided, and underneath the church is a large hall, for Sunday School and other purposes, which is not yet finished.”
The cost has been approximately £3900, of which £2400 had been raised. The membership in March 1912 had been 39, and they remained at that level until 1918 when it rose to 68. The number of reserved seats was 130, and even in 1918 average attendances were 40 in the morning and 80 in the evening.
The church’s greatest benefactor, Councillor W.F. Jackson, died in February 1918 and was remembered in a window,
The church remained in debt throughout the 1930s and in 1942 amalgamated with Broomhill, on the Nether Green site.
The newly amalgamated church was renamed St. George’s, Nether Green. A further amalgamation with Ranmoor Methodist Church took place in 1963, again on the Nether Green site.
Nether Green Methodist Church continues to this day, as can be seen in the photograph.
To learn more, see:
Flavell, Neville ‘From Goole Green to Nether Green: the roots and history of Hallam Methodist Church 1756-2006.